Batteries...name brand vs. generic

Discussion in 'The Bench' started by Rob Ross, Jun 27, 2017.

  1. Rob Ross

    Rob Ross Well-Known Member

    My wife was wondering if the generic named batteries are just as good a name brand...anyone have any real world experience to share? I'm talking AAA, AA, C, D, etc...
     
  2. 1972Mach1

    1972Mach1 Just some M.M.O.G. guy.....

    I'm about as big of a bargain guy as anyone I know, but to me, they honestly don't seem like they last nearly as long as the "good" brands. I bought one of those 80 packs or whatever of AAAs from Harbor Freight, and I swear over half of them were dead out of the package.....
     
  3. blyons79

    blyons79 Well-Known Member

    I bought a bag full of cheap batteries from Harbor Freight. I filled up my extended Smith & Wesson MagLight with 4 D cell batteries a few months ago. Went to turn it on last week and all of the batteries in it were corroded and leaking. Ruined my favorite flash light!
     
  4. Smokey15

    Smokey15 So old that I use AARP bolts.

    I have noticed that as well. We buy name brand. Difference in price is well worth it.
     
  5. UticaGeoff

    UticaGeoff Well-Known Member

    I have had great luck with Walgreens brand - get them when they are buy one get one free. I have had no luck with ones from Aldi's - do not last.

    UticaGeoff
     
  6. sriley531

    sriley531 Excommunicado

    I recently bought some of the bulk pack cheapies from Amazon ("Amazon basics" I think is the name on them). They seem to be holding up decently, but I agree, seems the off brands rarely hold up as well as Energizer/Duracell/etc. Get what ya pay for with batteries I suppose.
     
  7. Rob Ross

    Rob Ross Well-Known Member

    Thanks everyone!
     
  8. John Codman

    John Codman Platinum Level Contributor

    The Federal Aviation Administration has approved Duracell batteries as the only "off the shelf" batteries that are allowed for use in aircraft emergency locator beacons. That's good enough for me.
     
    Last edited: Jun 29, 2017
    superlark likes this.
  9. tdacton

    tdacton Gold Level Contributor

    In my sound deadening headphones I use while mowing, the cheap Sunbeam brand don't last 1/2 as long as an Energizer or a Duracell AA
     
  10. Roberta

    Roberta Buick Berta

    Name brands almost always, especially ones made in USA!
     
  11. bhambulldog

    bhambulldog 1955 76-RoadmasterRiviera

    Duracell, is what I have the best luck with.

    The off brand do not last half as long.
     
  12. BadBrad

    BadBrad Got 4-speed?

    To the chagrin of my kids I moved on to rechargeables. I think for everyday use there's no better investment.
     
  13. yachtsmanbill

    yachtsmanbill Well-Known Member

    Compare two like packages by weight. Considerable difference! ws
     
  14. cjeboyle

    cjeboyle Gold Level Contributor

    Years ago we did a "spin pop challenge" with duracells vs Ray o vac and the underdog ray o vac where a bit better. Point being you can save a few bucks on batteries but don't go too far down the chain or quality will most definitely suffer.
    Cliff
     
  15. 73Electra 225

    73Electra 225 Well-Known Member

    To everyone buying regular Alkaline batteries, you need to seriously look into investing in NiMH. I use a Maha charger with a mix of Powerex Imedion and Eneloop AA/AAA. I use them for the remotes, xbox remote, mouse and Febreeze air fresheners. Haven't had to buy a regular AA or AAA in the last few years now. Actually waiting on an EBL charger and 6 pack of 9V Li-ion to try out in my testing equipment for the shop.
     
    bhambulldog likes this.
  16. 87GN_70GS

    87GN_70GS Well-Known Member

    After losing a few good flashlights to leaking corroded alkaline batteries, I now use nothing but Energizer Ultimate Lithiums, primary (non-rechargeable) in everything. More voltage and current capacity than alkaleaks, longer shelf life, better cold temp performance. If i need a D, I use a 3AA-to-D adapter (cheap, off ebay). If I need C, 3AAA-to-C adapter. Buy 'em at Walmart
     
    blyons79 likes this.
  17. TexasT

    TexasT Texas, where are you from

    I buy those sunbeam at the dollar tree(I also get toothpaste and bleach there) and for a dollar ill change em rather than paying five to six times as much for the Duracell or energizer . But as pointed out I buy the fancy batteries for the"storm" flashlight and smoke detector. But for tv remote and such the cheap is better to me.
     

Share This Page