Titan submarine accident

Discussion in 'The Bench' started by Mark Demko, Jun 22, 2023.

  1. dmfconsult

    dmfconsult Devil in a Blue Dress

    Not sure what you guys are seeing, but this sub did have at least one window (portal) in the nose.
     
    Max Damage likes this.
  2. Luxus

    Luxus Gold Level Contributor

    Yea, I didn't know that in the beginning but I'm seeing that window in the nose now.
     
  3. Max Damage

    Max Damage I'm working on it!

    Also, just to be clear this was it's 14th excursion to the Titanic wreckage. RIP.
     
    PGSS likes this.
  4. Houndogforever

    Houndogforever Silver Level contributor

    14??? And probably never re-checked for any damage after the first couple, then it was "proven"
     
    PGSS likes this.
  5. 2manybuicks

    2manybuicks Founders Club Member

    They are not going to find any bodies or even remains. Suppose the pressure was 5,000 PSI. Put a wall to your left. one to your right. Call the area of your body 5 square feet = 720 sq in. Those two walls propelled by 5 000 PSI would hit you with a combined force of 3,600,000 lbs = 1,800 tons. Squish! Nothing but jelly.
     
    1973gs, 446379H and Luxus like this.
  6. LARRY70GS

    LARRY70GS a.k.a. "THE WIZARD" Staff Member

  7. TrunkMonkey

    TrunkMonkey Totally bananas

    Not trying to be crass.
    One of the "benefits" to this fiasco, is the great number of people that did not pay attention in science class in school, or partied to hard in college, are doing some research and learning a good bit about physics, physiology, and other topics.

    [​IMG]
     
    1973gs and 73 Stage-1 like this.
  8. Luxus

    Luxus Gold Level Contributor

    Yea, I figured they probably didn't even register the implosion. Which is a blessing of course.
     
  9. LARRY70GS

    LARRY70GS a.k.a. "THE WIZARD" Staff Member

    Yeah, I'm thinking they never knew what hit them.
     
    Dadrider likes this.
  10. 446379H

    446379H Well-Known Member

    If they want to go down with a chicken wire & bubble gum machine fine , taking the teenager is beyond reprehensible .
     
    Dadrider and PGSS like this.
  11. red67wildcat

    red67wildcat Well-Known Member

    19 is a Adult
     
    Max Damage likes this.
  12. John Codman

    John Codman Platinum Level Contributor

    Again, I am not going to bash anybody. It has been mentioned here that hull designs are calculated for a specific number of cycles. An example would be the Aloha Airlines 737 that blew a significant part of it's fuselage off in a flight over Hawaii. The pressurization life of that 727 was 75,000 cycles. When the fuselage finally failed, the airplane was at about 94,000 cycles. There was still enough of the airplane to land it under control. In the case of the Titan, obviously the cycle life of the vessel had not been correctly calculated. Hopefully, the takeaway from this is that things like cycle-life will have to be established before we do this kind of thing again. We learn from our mistakes. Sadly, some of those mistakes result in the loss of life.
     
    Last edited: Jun 24, 2023
    Premier 350 and Mark Demko like this.
  13. knucklebusted

    knucklebusted Well-Known Member

    Per my previous post, we DID learn something.

    Have you ever seen the implosion/collapse of a tanker trailer? Imagine it being made of carbon fiber. Instead of a violent collapse of metal smashing them, it would have likely shattered around them, shards of CF hitting them, razor sharp from all directions. It's a good thing they were already dead.

    My question is, did they hear it starting to give? It collapsed so quickly, I wonder if they had a moment to ponder their demise or if the CEO said it was normal?

    Jump to 2:10 into the video.
     
    Mark Demko and Mister T like this.
  14. bw1339

    bw1339 Well-Known Member

    I have never designed a submarine, but if that is the pressure hull...

    [​IMG]
     
    Mark Demko and 446379H like this.
  15. Luxus

    Luxus Gold Level Contributor

    You are not wrong. But subs normally have a double hull.
     
  16. pbr400

    pbr400 68GS400

    I’m sure they put some Permatex on the threads…

    Patrick
     
  17. TrunkMonkey

    TrunkMonkey Totally bananas

    At 9000 feet below the surface, the implosion would have had structure moving at the 2000 feet per second. Think rifle shot, or Mach 2 or 1500MPH. These folks would have been dead in a couple of nanoseconds and far faster then they could even receive a signal to the brain that anything even happened. Not to mention, the extreme heat and pressure spike would have resulted in a spontaneous detonation/combustion. Over before they knew anything.

    And the entire time the vessel is descending, it is experiencing continual noises from the pressure exerted and popping, creaking, groaning. So, they "never heard" the one that got them.

    Think lighting hammer hitting an ant on an anvil. Just, gone in an instant.
    When you hear people talking about "they died instantly", this is a literal reality in this case.

    Retired USAF, I know a thing about pressurization, negative pressure effects and catastrophic failure of quite a number of components. I have experienced/seen things.

    My cousin was a Navy Bubble head (Nuke guy), we talked about a lot of this stuff.

    He feared a Kursk situation and welcomed the implosion if anything ever went wrong.
     
    12lives and Premier 350 like this.
  18. bw1339

    bw1339 Well-Known Member

    Based on the photos of its construction I have seen, that seems unlikely. How many hulls capable of over 5000 psi can one fit there anyway?
     
  19. Fox's Den

    Fox's Den 355Xrs

    I read a article that sharks that had tracking devices on them started to head to the site.
     
    PGSS and TrunkMonkey like this.
  20. TrunkMonkey

    TrunkMonkey Totally bananas

    Those are actually frickin' laser beams attached to their heads!
     
    Fox's Den and john.schaefer77 like this.

Share This Page